PAKISTAN IS STILL A NATION IN THE MAKING

Pakistani Flag. Source - Wikipedia

Mukesh Devrari

Pakistan has been carved out in 1947. It was an artificial nation. Islam was used as a tool to create a nation by encouraging separatism in Muslim majority areas. Violence was used as a tool to pressurize British government and Congress party. Finally, they gave in to the demands of Muslim separatists who claimed that Hindus and Muslims cannot stay together in one nation.

Pakistan has seven provinces – Baluchistan, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Punjab, Sindh, Federally Administered Tribal Areas, Occupied Kashmir and Gilgit–Baltistan. Out of those 7 provinces, four are completely under the control of Punjabi Muslims. Many Indian Muslims believe that Pakistan was created and imagined as a home for all South Asian Muslims. Only after partition, they realized that it was not the case. It provided a home to the Muslim elite who were not satisfied with the democratic turn India was about to take after the end of the British rule.

Out of the seven provinces of Baluchistan, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Federally Administered Tribal Areas have been kept under the control of Pakistan through the use of guns and military might. People in those areas are struggling against the onslaught of Pakistan state. The Pakistani military has brutally suppressed the separatist movement. 

Pakistani armed forces ruthlessly eliminate all dissenting voices in those areas. Pro Pakistan Islamic terror groups have been given free hand in these areas. They function with complete impunity. Hundreds of young men have disappeared from those areas. If people of these conflict zones will be given an opportunity, they will prefer the path of liberty and independence.

No religious minorities believe in the idea of Pakistan. Hindus, Christians and Sikhs were already suffocating. The rise in extreme Wahabi Islam cornered the Islamic sects as well. Genocide of Hazara and Ahmadiya community is on a full swing. Power and influence of Islamic fundamentalists are growing significantly, left-leaning liberal intellectuals have been cornered. Many of them are being described as Indian agents and traitors.  

When Pakistan was created, it was not very different from India. It had considerable minorities and people in that part of India were also highly diverse. Now Punjabis own Pakistan. They represent the mullah military nexus. It is unimaginable in any democratic nation, Punjab opposes the census to hide the true character of diversity in Pakistan, as a change in demographics will lead the demand for change in resource allocation and seats in the national legislature. Pakistani Punjab has ensured that the census is not conducted since 1998. In 2017, finally census was conducted, but with a lot of questions on its validity and authenticity.

The whole approach towards existence and identity in both nations are very different from each other. Pakistan sees the justification for its creation in the failures of the Indian state. Whenever news related to beef lynching, riots reach Pakistan, people rejoice and celebrate that Pakistan was created to stop the same fate for all Indian Muslims. However, Pakistan is rarely discussed in any depth manner in India. Most of the mainstream discourse about Pakistan revolves around bilateral conflicts and export of terrorism to India and other parts of the world. There is a lot more to that nation, which is still in making.

 Still, Pakistan has not reached the point of no return. Democratic leadership willing to bring change by discarding the excessive influence of military and Mosque can transform Pakistan into a modern state. Although it is unlikely to happen if Pakistan will insist on the assimilation of Kashmir, feed disproportionate amount of money to the military at the cost of its development. 

end. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

TRANSNATIONAL MEDIA OWNERSHIP AND ISSUES OF SOVEREIGNTY AND SECURITY

Image
Mukesh Devrari  Transnational media ownership means ownership of media assets by global corporate houses around the world. The word 'transnational' can easily be easily replaced with the term multinational. In other words, when a multinational company owns media companies around the globe that company can be described as a transnational media organization. There are plenty of such organizations, but most vilified among all is owned by Rupert Murdoch.  The nature of media is very different. As you all know media is a plural form of the medium. Production of films, TV serials, drama, theatre and other wings of the cultural industry are also owned by western media companies. Here, the meaning of the word transnational can be extended. Not necessarily western media companies own assets in the third world countries. They create their work in the west and sell it around the world.   It has long been a complaint against western media companies that wherever they g...
Read more

RESURGENCE OF NAZIS IN GERMAN, ITS NOT OVER YET FOR JEWS

Image
Book Review  Mukesh Devrari Eldad Beck’s new book ‘Germany, at odds’ reminds us about the resurgence of German nationalism in the 21 st century. German patriotism and racial nationalism, popularly known as Nazism, posed a threat to humanity in the 20 th century. Germans would like to forget about their troubling history. It reminds them of their barbarity and unconscious brutal tendencies. This book yet again proves that Nazi ideology did not end with the suicide of Adolf Hitler and hanging of many of his associates. Hitler was an elected leader. He came to power through democracy. When Jews were killed in concentration camps and pulled on roads from their houses like cattle, the German population remained silent. In connivance with their leaders, German population attempted extermination of Jews from the face of the earth. Now, almost 75 years after the end of the Second World War, Germans are trying to forget their past. They are attempting to embark on a pa...
Read more

Bacha Khan: One of pre-1947 India’s greatest leaders

Image
Mukesh Devrari The tallest Pashtun leader before the independence was Abdul Gaffar Khan, also known as Frontier Gandhi. He was one of the most fascinating and towering figures of Indian National Movement who preached truth and non-violence to his people who are mostly known for their tribal culture of revenge. He was the pre-eminent figure of Indian National Congress. “The British just about knew how to contend with vegetarian Hindus who raised slogans rather than guns, but Bacha Khan’s “unarmed army” of Pashtuns, which turned the martial race stereotype on its head, left them completely bewildered” (Shamsie, 2016) .   After Congress accepted the partition plan, he famously said, “You have thrown us in front of the wolves” (Tempest, 1988) . “He rejected a separate Muslim homeland and sought instead to join India to avoid Punjabi domination”  (Schofield, 2011, p. 38) . Due to his influence, many Muslims from the region migrated to India at the time of partition (Shukla...
Read more