Posts

Showing posts with the label Power struggle

CPC MUST ACCEPT LAC AS THE INTERNATIONAL BORDER FOR PEACE

Image
Mukesh Devrari In my opinion, it is futile to seek confrontation for few kilometres of land in this day and age on the grounds that hundreds of years ago or thousands of years ago it belonged to us, now it belongs to our neighbours, but we don’t accept it. China’s military may succeed in intruding at certain places, but it would not be possible for China to substantially alter the 3488-kilometre long boundary. If CPC thinks it can change the LAC as per its imaginary borders with India military force, then it must be looking at the full-fledged attack on India which might result in the killing of hundreds of thousands of soldiers and civilians on both sides. If the human lives are important than it is immaterial whether the widow lives in Shanghai or Mumbai. After much bloodshed, even if China succeeds in capturing Tawang region of Arunachal Pradesh and parts of Union Territory of Ladakh. Will it be worth it? Although CPC can go to any extent to achieve its objectives. ...

UNIFORM CIVIL CODE IS NOT ABOUT HINDU DOMINANCE

Image
Screen shot from the website of The Hindu.  Mukesh Devrari In the morning I came across a column written against uniform civil code in the editorial page of ‘The Hindu’. The essay was written by Nivedita Menon. She is a professor at JNU, New Delhi and describes herself as a feminist scholar. In her column titled ‘It isn’t about the woman’, she gave reasons to support the continuation of Sharia based Muslim personal law in India and argued against prohibiting polygamy and triple talaq. She described the Uniform Civil Code as a Hindu agenda to impose Hindu laws on Muslims. I could resist myself and scribbled a few lines to critique her arguments. It is important to critically examine her grotesque narrative on the issue. She is denying democratic space available to Muslim women in secular democracies like India. According to her even in secular democracies if Muslims women need any right, they should find it within the Islamic faith.  Recently a Muslim w...

HOW LONG INDIA CAN FACE UNREST IN KASHMIR?

Image
Photo courtesy -  Mukhtar Khan, Nam News Network   Mukesh Devrari Burhan Wani was killed by armed forces. He was the Kashmiri militant, who used to pose in fancy military uniforms on social networking sites to attract youth to join dreaded terrorist group Hizbul Mujahideen. Kashmir Muslims started protesting after the pictures of his dead body were circulated by the media. What else could have been the fate of an armed militant? What else his sympathizers were expecting? He was destined to face the consequences for his choice. All separatist elements are responsible for his death who encourage youth to pick arms. For the loss of this life and many others like him, those are responsible who glorify and glamorize the Islamic terrorism in Kashmir.    Indians strategists must learn a few lessons from this incident. Killings of these high profile terrorists should be handled delicately. Whether like it or not, in Kashmir valley terrorists enjoy widespre...

LAND ACQUISITION SHOULD BE SIMPLIFIED FOR RAPID INDUSTRIALIZATION

Image
Mukesh Devrari During the tenure of Congress, party country came to stand still. It was described as policy paralysis. There were many reasons. During its tenure, Congress decided to hear the complaints of farmers that their land is being acquired by state governments arbitrarily for the benefit of corporate groups.  In West Bengal CPIM decided to acquire land from farmers for failed Tata small car project. Farmers agitated against government fiercely.  Congress as a true left-leaning political party provided relief to farmers at the cost of long term benefits to the nation. For some, it was very encouraging to see that the mainstream political party in India is willing to take the side with the weaker sections of society.  According to the detractors of the Congress party, this decision led to the complete stagnation in developmental projects. It became impossible for states to acquire land. Many of the Chief Ministers in congress govern state opposed the bill...

STRUGGLE FOR GENDER EQUALITY CONTINUES IN INDIA

Image
Mukesh Devrari How the feminists should fight for gender equality in India is an elusive question? What should they demand is a settled narrative?  At the first level, feminists should fight to reform the law. It must be based on rationality. It must not be discriminatory and biased. At least women in India are fortunate that the moral conscience keepers of our society were always sympathetic to the concerns of feminists. Immediately after the independence first Prime Minister of India decided to amend the Hindu Code Bill on the modern lines despite the opposition from Hindu fanatics within Congress party. He successfully dealt with fundamentalism of the majority community but decided to bow its head in front of fanatics within the Muslim minority. Perhaps that’s why uniform civil code could not be implemented in India. Feminists in India must ask for the changes in laws that are gender biased and discriminatory. That is the first battleground. At the second level,...

THREATS OF COMMUNAL WRITING - BEWARE

Image
Mukesh Devrari What is communal writing? It includes a style of writing, which tends to create rift among different communities. It also promotes and preaches hatred. It encourages communities to indulge in violence against each other. It draws a picture as if communities are pitted against each other and always vying to establish hegemony over each other. In a country like India, communal writing can lead to rioting, loss of life and property. India has seen many communal conflagrations. In 1984 riots many Sikhs were killed by the supporters of congress party after Prime Minister Indira Gandhi was murdered by her Sikh bodyguards. In the ensuing riots after the demolition of controversial Babri Mosque in 1992thousands of Hindus and Muslims killed each other brutally. In 2002 Gujrat riots many Muslims were killed in Gujrat with the connivance of state government led by Narendra Modi.   Communal writing is an immoral thing, but at times even debate around the so...

PRIVATIZATION OF HIGHER EDUCATION IS EVIL IN THIRD WORLD COUNTRIES

Image
This author has written this news (in picture) in Garhwal Post in the year 2006. It is a small newspaper published from Dehradun.    Mukesh Devrari It started in the early nineties. It was the part of the initiation of economic reform juggernaut. Successive governments in India accepted the policy prescription from neo-liberal thinkers that the education sector should be opened for private players. All opposite suggestions were dismissed as leftist arguments, which had perhaps lost their potency with the disintegration of the Soviet Union. Humanist thinkers reminded the government that it must keep the health and education sector in its own hands. Hospitals and Universities cannot be allowed to function with the sole intention of making a profit, but all alternative discourse was  out-rightly  rejected. The result was an innumerable number of private colleges and universities cropped up around the country. Some of them are churning trained technical ...

PRACTICAL WAYS TO DEAL WITH MAOIST REBELLION IN INDIA

Image
Mukesh Devrari  Experts from across the the country participated in the round Table Conference on ‘Naxalism, Development and Crisis of Governance in the Context of Jharkhand’, which was organized by the Centre for Human Rights and Conflict Management of Central University of Jharkhand on 26th March 2014. Conference was divided into four sessions ‘Is the Maoist Movement Critical’, ‘Dynamics and Drivers’, ‘The State as Problem and Solution’ and ‘Can the Future Be Better’. Open invitation was extended to all faculty members and students of Central University Jharkhand to attend the round table and freely express their views. However, during the discussion none of the participants explicitly mentioned that Maoists are actually fighting an ideological war with the state. Many of them preferred to describe rebellion in central India as land reform movement which has been degenerated into law and order problem of large proportions.  Practical suggestions were put f...

IS NEOLIBERAL AGENDA A BRAHMIN CONSPIRACY?

Image
Mukesh Devrari India is a strange country. It was a mystery, it is a mystery and it will always remain a mystery. This is how many people like to describe this place. It is nothing but an exaggeration. Logic does not work here, pure cruelty works here better. Elites in India still consist of upper castes. Perhaps that is why inhumanity and unscrupulousness is more at display here. Caste biases and prejudices flow in the veins of Indians. It is another thing that everyone, mainly people belonging to upper castes who are living in cities, denies that caste tendencies exist in our society at all. They also assert forcefully that they do not believe that caste matters at all.  Caste is perhaps more pervasive in India then many of us like to believe.  Caste is similar to race. People are educated and do not want to be branded as casteist as nobody in west likes to branded as racist. Despite of the claims it is not only the strength of character, which matters in our societ...

WHAT IS POLITICAL COMMUNICATION?

Image
Mukesh Devrari Mass Communication and political participation have meshed in each other to the extent that politics in modern mass society cannot exist without it. Mass Communication is used to ensure political participation which ensures the legitimacy of the ruling class. Every type of governing system needs to interact with people and the global community for a variety of reasons. It led to the growth of political communication as a practice and subject matter of study. Political Communication?  Political communication is a transmission of politically relevant information to the ruled by the rulers. It is a dynamic element of the political system and the processes of political socialization, political participation and political recruitment are dependent on it. Karl Deutsch in his book ‘The Nerves of Government’ says, “There are two ways to study political communication. One is to study it as a black and white affair, where means of mass communication exists...

NATIVE CULTURES ARE UNDER THREAT

Image
Mukesh Devrari  William Westerman Adjunct Professor at the City University of New York claimed in his paper titled ‘Disruptions to Culture: The Refugee Experience, Cultural Sustainability and Finding Accord with Indigenous Folks’ that native and migrant populations could live peacefully side by side by respecting each other in five different areas of human activity. He gave a simple theory in his paper presented in a seminar organized by  Centre for Tribal Folklore, Language and Literature of   Central University of Jharkhand on 12 Jan. 2014.  Westerman lists five arenas, where he claims that a varied set of people should treat each other respectfully. He increases the dictionary of ‘being respectful’ for his theory.  Here respectfully means acting without any coercion, force and exploitation. Here is a remedy given by him.   First is land, the only finite supply of land is available on earth and on every nation also and native inhabitants be...